Indigenous courts, the way of the future

31 August 2018

Valmaine Toki for web
Associate Professor Valmaine Toki, proposing indigenous courts for Māori.

An advocate for an improved justice system for Māori, Dr Valmaine Toki has researched and visited indigenous courts in comparative jurisdictions and is now calling for the establishment of indigenous courts in New Zealand.

The University of Waikato associate professor considers if Māori were to have their cases heard in courts where ‘tikanga Māori’ and ‘therapeutic jurisprudence’ are practised, then there would be far fewer Māori in New Zealand prisons and far fewer cases of recidivism.

While only 15% of New Zealand’s population, Māori comprise 50% of the male prison population and 60% of the female prison population; statistics that haven’t changed in 30 years. This disproportionate situation is similar for indigenous peoples in other countries.

Dr Toki, from Te Piringa Faculty of Law at the University of Waikato, has researched indigenous law and courts in New Zealand, Canada, Australia, the USA, Ecuador and the Pacific. She was the first New Zealander appointed as an Expert Member on the United Nations Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues, and recently published a book Indigenous Courts, Self-Determination and Criminal Justice.

“This situation has been motivational – indigenous peoples’ rights to self-determination, tino rangatiratanga, with a focus on criminal justice. Clearly the system isn’t working for Māori. Fundamental principles such as reciprocity, taking responsibility, whanaungatanga and balance are principles that should be recognised and implemented in the criminal justice process,” Dr Toki says.

Her book gives historical context to the present situation, current criminal justice initiatives, the Treaty of Waitangi’s place in the New Zealand legal system, the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples and Self-determination, and initiatives from other countries.

She proposes two ways that indigenous courts could be introduced, either by building on the marae-based justice system that has been introduced for rangatahi (youth) and matariki (for adults), or expanding the jurisdiction of the Māori Land Court to include criminal and civil matters for Māori.

”There are arguments for both, but first there has to be the political will in place to effect a change to the current system.  It would be good if some positive and practical steps came from the recent Criminal Justice Summit. That would be a start. Simply from a fiscal perspective, considering the expense of incarceration, that money could be better spent on health or education,” Dr Toki says.


For more information about her book, go to

One reviewer, Professor of Law Elena Marchetti from Griffith University in Australia had this to say about  Indigenous Courts, Self-Determination and Criminal Justice.

This excellent book, authored by Professor Valmaine Toki, explores how contemporary court structures have adapted to incorporate elements of Māori law and how the New Zealand legal system could go further in establishing a specialist Tikanga Court, utilizing principles of therapeutic jurisprudence.  One of the major contributions the book makes to scholarship in the area of Indigenous courts, is that it maps what Indigenous courts currently exist in New Zealand and in other jurisdictions such as the USA, Canada, Australia, Ecuador and the Pacific.  It is not easy to find this information and it rarely appears in one source.

Related stories

Three generations of whānau woven into the University of Waikato

Te Whare Wānanga o Waikato is Maria Huata’s tūrangawaewae.

How antiquated legal language undermines complainants in cases of sexual assault

Dr Brenda Midson examines one of New Zealand’s most notorious sexual misconduct cases.

When machine learning, Twitter and te reo Māori merge

Researchers have whittled down a massive 8 million tweets, to a more manageable 1.2 million…

Summer Research Scholarship wrap up

A successful summer of research was wrapped up at a function held at the Gallagher…

The significance of Te Tiriti o Waitangi

Sandy Morrison and Ingrid Huygens look at role of the Treaty, 179 years after its…

Who should govern Mars?

Dr Anna Marie Brennan looks at whether Elon Musk could rule a new world.

Dancing her way to Nepal

Kaylee Bird is swapping New Zealand summer for a trek up the Himalayas as she…

Culturally responsive teaching in a globalized world

What are the best ways for teachers to deal with increasingly diverse classrooms?

How a default union membership could help reduce income inequality

Researchers argue that making union membership the default option would help reduce inequality while protecting…

Al Gillespie in Ghent

Big medal win for law professor

Professor Al Gillespie has been awarded two of Belgium's top academic medals for his research…

When two Heads are better than one

Anaru Palmer and Leah Owen, departing head prefects of Tauranga Boys’ and Tauranga Girls’ Colleges,…

Photo of Ngairo Eruera, the new kaiako of Te Tohu Paetahi in Tauranga

Returning to your roots

The words of the Six60 song ‘Don’t Forget Your Roots’ spring to mind when talking…