Dean of Computing and Mathematical Sciences Professor Geoff Holmes looks at magnitudes of scholarship and the Millennium Prize Problems.

In recent years, Hollywood has shown a great deal of interest in the Millennium Prizes. These prizes are for the solution of seven problems in mathematics that have evaded proof by some of the finest minds in history. Each prize is worth one million US dollars but even with this level of incentive only one of the prizes has thus far been claimed (for a proof of the Poincaré Conjecture). The “P vs NP” problem has been covered by an episode of Elementary (Sherlock Holmes, no relation) where the solver was unfortunately murdered; the film “Gifted” covered the Navier-Stokes equation (implying that a proof had been produced by the dead mother of the focus of the film—her gifted daughter). Unfortunately, "Proof by Hollywood" is not really a recognised technique in mathematical research. Some other recent productions have been about famous mathematicians who have studied some of these problems: “The Man Who Knew Infinity” (Ramanujan) and “The Imitation Game” (Alan Turing).

Professor Geoff Holmes.

One of the unsolved problems, posed in 1859 by Bernhard Riemann, is the Riemann Hypothesis (like Fermat I have no margin to explain this problem but you can read an explanation). Last December the Faculty of Computing and Mathematical Sciences celebrated the publication by Cambridge University Press of two volumes entitled "Equivalents of the Riemann Hypothesis", by Emeritus Professor Kevin Broughan. The volumes cover arithmetic and computational equivalents. Equivalents to the problem are problems that if proved or disproved immediately prove or disprove the Riemann Hypothesis. Because there are so many equivalents, solving one of these solves all of the others instantaneously. The Riemann Hypothesis has links to theory about the distribution of the prime numbers, which is one of Kevin’s research areas of interest.

Most mathematicians believe that the Riemann Hypothesis is true. For example, it is known to be true computationally for the first trillion values that were tested. However, this approach to a mathematician, is about as rigorous as "Proof by Hollywood".

To provide a perspective on the gravity of this problem to mathematicians Kevin quotes David Hilbert, the renowned German mathematician, who was once asked, “If you were to die and be revived after five hundred years, what would you then do?” Hilbert replied that he would ask “Has someone proved the Riemann hypothesis?”

I mention the celebration of the publication of these books in particular because in the age of the Performance Based Research Fund it is rare to celebrate scholarship of this magnitude. For Kevin they represent just two of the four required Nominated Research Outputs. Research texts are certainly not common in the computing and mathematical sciences and any mathematician tackling one of these problems would certainly have a hard job convincing their head of department that it would be productive. Andrew Wiles, solver of Fermat's Theorem was famously hiding his work from colleagues at Princeton. The remaining unsolved problems not mentioned above are: the Hodge Conjecture, the Birch and Swinnerton-Dyer Conjecture and the Yang–Mills and Mass Gap. Interested readers may find more details about these famous unsolved problems in mathematics.

Related stories

When a cyber-intruder is in your home

Locks and traditional alarms can’t keep cyber-criminals out, but a Waikato researcher has developed an…

Forging a vision for security in a new age of disruptive techno-politics

Experts from around the country and the world have gathered at University of Waikato to…

Waikato alumni doing their bit

Three University of Waikato graduates are the driving force behind an innovative project to provide…


Keeping your drone in the air

Joseph Simblett is making a drone control that will fit in the palm of your…

Tyler Marriner

Playing in the blockchain

The blockchain is that decentralised database that keeps all records of digital transactions, but what…

Challenging stereotypes in the digital industry

Alaa Abuellif may be studying in a male-dominated field, but she’s determined to encourage other…

Waikato students take out the grand prize for the NZ Cyber Security Challenge

Hundreds of aspiring cyber-crime fighters tackled a range of increasingly tough tasks, hacking drones and…

Facing the challenge of women in cyber security

The NZ Cyber Challenge is taking up the issue of the under representation of women…

Students fast-track to work

At Rocketspark’s office in Cambridge, the staff all have one thing in common. They are…

Hacking your holiday

Dr Joe Burton looks at how cyber criminals are increasingly targeting the tourism market.

Scott Brown and Thye Way

US ambassador drops in

US Ambassador Scott Brown was keen to hear about research being done in cyber security…

Cree and Frank web

What on Earth is that?

Scientists are using artificial intelligence to quickly identify pest plants and insects.