Age responsive pedagogies: 'Preschool' ECE teachers interrogate their dialogues with and about two-year-olds
Emerging Researcher: Bridgette Redder
Project Dates: January 2017 - February 2019
Ten experienced teachers from two mixed age early childhood education settings catering for two year-olds alongside their older peers engaged in a video-based inquiry that allowed a slowing down of their pedagogical processes. The purpose of their inquiry was to understand what two year-old dialogues ‘look like’ in ‘preschool’ settings traditionally oriented to older peers as a source of pedagogical insight. According to dialogic theory, dialogues are not only central to learning – they ARE learning – and this is no less true for two year-olds, who have unique ways of being and becoming in ECE spaces. Such dialogues allow for expression of multiple ideas and perspectives which can lead to shared meaning-making – allowing teachers to see learning potential.
1. To make explicit the specialised practices required of teachers – who have traditionally worked with three to four year-olds – in their pedagogical dialogues with and about two year-olds who are increasingly attending their services, and
2. To identify, articulate and ultimately improve the pedagogical experience for two year-olds in ECE settings that traditionally cater for older children by making explicit the dialogic relationship between teacher (and peer) interactions with two year-olds, and the significance of these for learning..
Why was this research important?
When the dialogic efforts of teachers are held up for scrutiny, teachers are able to re-vision their pedagogies and practices in ways that are inclusive of younger learners. By appreciating the unique dialogues that comprise two year-old learning experiences in ‘preschool’ settings, teachers can alter and better appreciate their learning potential for all.
The study provided important pedagogical insights into the nature of dialogues that occurred for two year-olds in these ‘preschool’ settings. Two year-old dialogues were typically comprised of nonverbal and verbal language combinations or non-verbal language use only. They included watching, moving freely in the ‘preschool’ space and connecting fleeting language events. When recognised by teachers, these findings gave great insight into the learning priorities of two year-olds, which were expressed through encounters which pulled toward or away from shared meaning with others including older peers who were now seen as pedagogical partners. In response to their discoveries, teachers altered their pedagogical strategies - using more nonverbal-verbal combinations, less probing as opposed to clarifying questioning (offer/instruction/suggest), increased levels of demonstrating, watchfulness, and tolerance for alternative routes of inquiry based on two year-olds’ strategic orientations. Two year-olds’ strategic orientations became increasingly apparent when teachers recognised the importance for two year-olds in ‘going against the grain’. Teachers significantly slowed down their dialogues to pay attention to two year-old priorities. They adjusted policies and assessments to reflect their revised understandings. Interestingly, teachers did not find the need to make significant adjustments to the environment as they recognised the learning potential across diverse learning contexts (genre) within the ‘preschool’.
Implications for practice
Thinking deeply about two year-olds as dialogue partners through a dialogic lens allows teachers to ‘see’ learning in more expansive ways – not just for two year-olds but for older peers as well as themselves. Teachers are encouraged to take the time to engage with dialogue in its broadest sense – as a series of strategic orientations on the part of two year-olds. When teachers take the time to carefully scrutinise language, through fine-tuned analysis, and are prepared to critically dialogue about its significance, there are many pedagogical riches to be found. These lead to more meaningful encounters with two year-olds and an appreciation of their agentic acts as a source of shared meaning (intersubjectivity), and, importantly dissensus of meaning (alterity) in the ‘preschool’ environment. In particular, this means:
- Paying attention to the nuances of language, well beyond verbal communication alone, and inclusive of embodied language; as well as responding appropriately to these.
- Less talk without accompanying action (body language).
- Providing opportunities (and space) for two year-olds to negotiate meanings with people, places and things.
- Recognising that two year-olds are extremely capable and competent in their relationships with teachers and peers, when given the opportunity to be seen and heard.
- Celebrating learning potential in two year-old learning with their peers as co-pedagogues.
- Recognising the diverse opportunities that exist in ‘preschool’ learning contexts, and that several of these take place in underground spaces (which teachers may not always ‘see’).
- Appreciating that two year-olds have their own ways of being in ‘preschool’ environments, and, when given the opportunity to do so, will artfully manoeuvre themselves accordingly –dependent on the spaces, resources and people at their disposal, and their priorities.
- Increasing capacity for humour and fun – enjoying what two year-olds have to teach us.
- White, E.J. et al (2019). Age-responsive pedagogies: preschool teachers interrogate their dialogues with and about 2-year-olds. TLRI - PDF - 2.62 MB
- Outcomes poster - PDF - 248.11 KB
- White, E. J., Redder, B., Bennett, B., De Manser, B., Geddes, C., & Hjorth, C. (2018). Pedagogical dialogue with two year-olds in preschool settings: What do they look like? Early Childhood Folio. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.18296/ecf.222.2018
- White, E. J. (in preparation). Dialogues about dialogues: Articulating and enacting pedagogies with two year-olds in mixed age ECE.
- White. E. J. (2019). Panel discussion on methodological approaches (plenary), with Profs Sue Grieshaber and Linda Harrison, Australian Journal of Early Childhood Research Symposium: Multiplicity: Exploring multiple perspectives, agendas and methodologies in early childhood research, 14-15 February, Australian Catholic University, Melbourne.
- White, E. J., with TLRI team (2019). Launch of the Age Responsive Pedagogies Website, 20 February, University of Waikato.
- White, E. J. (2019). Pedagogical shifts and paradoxical thinking concerning age-based pedagogies in ECE curriculum seminar, 21 February, University of Waikato.
- White, E. J. (2018). ‘Seeing’ two year-olds in preschool through polyphonic eyes: Pedagogical shifts through video analysis. 2018 Research Forum Presentation to Early Childhood Australia (ECA), Victoria Branch, Melbourne, Australia.
- White, E. J (in absentia), Redder, B., & Geddes, C. (2018). Two year-olds in preschool problem or provocation. Keynote presentation for the Kidsfirst Kindergartens Conference, Christchurch, New Zealand. April 17-18.
- White, E. J., Redder, B., De Manser, B., Hjorth, C., Geddes, C. (2017). Dialogues with and about two year-olds in preschool. New Zealand Association for Research in Education Conference, Hamilton, New Zealand. November 21-23.
- White, E. J., Redder, B., Bennett, S. (2017). Toddlers in preschool: Problem or provocation? Inquire, Inspire 2017: A Tauranga research symposium. Tauranga, New Zealand. November 3.
- White, E. J. (2017). The trouble with two year-olds? Workshop presentation to Kidsfirst Kindergartens Conference, Christchurch, New Zealand. April.
- White, E. J (in absentia), Redder, B., Avenues Kindergarten & Gate Pa Preschool teaching teams. (2017). Early Insights from the field, Early Years Research Centre Conference, Hamilton, New Zealand. July 29.
Lannie Freed, Jayne White, Alisha Walker, Ange Taylor, Jean Harrison,
Shavaurn Bennett, Bridgette Redder
Caroline Hjorth, Annette Sheehy, Bev De Manser, Vicky Wilson